The property is sold. The file that kept you up at night has closed. And the statement of adjustments tells you what you already suspected: after the costs of sale, the realty taxes, and the payout, you are short.
I have written before about how power of sale works in Ontario and what the first 60 days after default should look like. This piece is about what comes after the sale — because for many lenders, especially in second position, the sale is not the end of the recovery. It's the halfway point.
The shortfall claim is a contract claim, not a mortgage claim
One of the reasons power of sale beats foreclosure for most Ontario lenders is that it preserves your right to sue the borrower personally. The mortgage contains a covenant to pay. When the sale proceeds don't retire the debt, you sue on that covenant for the difference — the shortfall, or deficiency.
That claim doesn't run against the property anymore. It runs against people: the borrower, and just as importantly, any guarantor or covenantor who signed onto the loan. On a lot of private files, the guarantor is where the recovery actually comes from.
The sale file you built is now your evidence
Here is the part lenders sometimes learn the hard way: the quality of your shortfall claim was largely decided during the sale, not after it.
A borrower facing a deficiency judgment has one main defence, and every borrower's lawyer knows it: the lender sold improvidently. Too fast, too cheap, without proper exposure to the market. If that argument lands, the court can reduce the shortfall by what the property should have fetched, and a claim can shrink dramatically or disappear.
The lenders who collect are the ones who can put an appraisal, a listing history, a marketing effort, and a defensible price in front of a judge and make the improvident-sale argument die quickly. If you ran a clean sale, the shortfall claim is usually a math exercise. If you didn't, it's a lawsuit.
Judgment is a piece of paper until you enforce it
Suppose the claim succeeds, or the borrower doesn't defend and you take default judgment. What you hold at that point is a judgment, not money.
Turning one into the other is its own exercise. In Ontario that generally means examining the debtor about their assets and income, filing writs against other real property they own, garnishing wages or accounts, and deciding, honestly, whether this debtor is worth pursuing. A judgment against someone with other equity-rich property is valuable. A judgment against someone with nothing is a filing fee.
That assessment should happen early, not after two years of litigation. On some files the right answer is to press hard. On others, it's a negotiated resolution.
Most shortfalls don't end in a trial
In practice, a large share of shortfall matters resolve by agreement: the borrower or guarantor acknowledges the debt, terms are documented, and a consent judgment sits behind the deal in case the terms aren't kept. It's faster, cheaper, and it converts a contested claim into an enforceable obligation without a trial.
Whether that's the right path on a given file depends on the numbers, the debtor, and the strength of the sale record. But it should always be on the table, a certain recovery of most of the shortfall often beats an uncertain recovery of all of it.
The takeaway
If you are a lender heading into a sale that looks like it will come up short, three things protect you: a sale process you can defend, an early and honest read on who can actually pay, and a willingness to resolve when resolution is the better economics. The shortfall claim is a real remedy in Ontario. It rewards lenders who treated the whole enforcement, from the notice of sale to the last writ, as one continuous file.
If you have a sale closing short, or a judgment you haven't been able to collect, that's a conversation worth having sooner rather than later.
About the author
Perry Benipal is a founding partner of Freedman Benipal Wu LLP and leads the firm's mortgage enforcement and lender recovery practice. He acts for private lenders, MICs, and mortgage brokerages across Ontario on power of sale, possession, receivership, and shortfall litigation.
- 📞 Call: 416-603-0167
- 💬 Have a file closing short? Request a consultation
This article is general information about Ontario law, not legal advice. Whether and how a shortfall can be recovered depends on the mortgage, the sale, and the parties on your particular file — get advice before acting.